Maybe the same way.â Â, Her fellow traveler on the path of secrecyÂ âÂ the 43-year-old woman with stage 4 breast cancer â says, in time, she may change her mind and tell everyone. ... No one can keep a secret. She has found two places to publicly share her hardest days and happiest milestonesÂ âÂ a blog called everythingleadstothis and on twitter as â43 year old woman.â She does it all anonymously. But she admits to mixed feelings about her transparency. I can personally count more than 20 people in my close circle. Sometimes, for instance, it’s just good business. I think it would be better for you to say something about spending more time with family and now youâre ready to get back into the work world,ââ recalled Dena, who lives in the Seattle area. In 2011, she stopped working to undergo a bone marrow transplant. Few know of any dark clouds in her life. She underwent a second transplant in 2013, also successful. She wanted to protect them from what can be scary online reading. No overall feeling of sickness or overt signs of illness. But she has a massive secret â stage 4 breast cancer, a metastatic recurrence, diagnosed one year ago. “There’s no right answer,” says Harden. Cancer ♋️ someone is keeping their family a secret | June 2019 Luminous Moochie. âI donât want to feel pitied. “If you’re a private person, you aren’t going to be asked a lot of questions,” she says. Dena didnât want anyone researching her rare ailments. Cancer is also an extremely difficult secret to keep for obvious reasons. But cancer is part of who I am. Keeping Cancer a Secret Email; Favorites; More; By Elizabeth Michaelson. The inner circle is tiny and tight, with no leaks.Â. But the actor never publicly discussed his condition and continued to work on major Hollywood films. These cancer researchers have family members and close friends who have or have died from cancer. Then, he explains that keeping their diagnosis fully secret may make it harder for them to ask for help when itâs neededÂ âÂ like getting a ride to treatment or grabbing a friendly ear to listen to fears, he said. “I was going to high school and it was a small town,” she says. When Melanie Young was first diagnosed with cancer, she decided to keep her diagnosis a secret from her work colleagues. She told her family, a handful of close friends and some of the men she dates. She said when they got older she would explain it. We encourage individuals with diverse backgrounds to apply and desire priority referrals of protected veterans. As any person with cancer knows, a cancer diagnosis also affects family members and friends. In Schnur's experience, people who tell their colleagues what they’re going through are often pleasantly surprised by the show of support. âOnce they recognize that from an intellectual perspective, it usually switches the situation around, and it opens the communication to a family. He’s not sure he made the right choice marrying her. Compare this with the Australian journalist Amanda Platell, whose older brother Michael died of lung cancer, aged just 40, without telling many of his other friends or family that he was even ill. “Everybody has to make their own decision as to what feels right to them and what doesn’t. âShe felt it would potentially grow more challenging for an employer to want to hire somebody whoâs had the health issue I had. “I hear that a lot with women who don’t want to tell their elderly parents.”. Keeping your cancer diagnosis a secret can sometimes be a better option. Those things sort of push my buttons. For some patients, the decision to not be fully open is simply a cool, financial calculation. This brings a nuanced level of secrecy. If they understand the truth of the diagnosis and … When Melanie Young was first diagnosed with cancer, she decided to keep her diagnosis a secret from her work colleagues. One quarter of women and almost a fifth of men diagnosed with cancer … She never wants to see even a flash of sorrow in the eyes of a friend. I argue that by keeping her cancer a secret, she runs the risk of doing the opposite: making cancer seem scarier and more worrisome. Theyâre doing it with this misconception that they donât want to burden the family members. But in cases where people heâs treating are facing grave diagnoses, the oncologist will offer guidance that heâs found to be healthy for the patient and their loved ones. Prior, he was a staff writer for The Denver Post, part of the newspaper's team that earned the Pulitzer Prize for coverage of the Columbine High School massacre.Â He has authored two books, including "The Third Miracle: an Ordinary Man, a medical Mystery, and a Trial of Faith."Â. QualityHealth Home > Cancer Health Center > Keeping Cancer a Secret. Doctors don't hide cancer from their patients, as they did with Bette Davis in the 1939 film "Dark Victory." Boseman, 43, was diagnosed with stage III colon cancer in 2016. Despite living in this tell-all, social-media age where more people seem comfortable discussing or tweeting their sniffles, scans and, for some, their cancers, this 43-year-old woman decided to reveal her illness only to a super-select few. Keeping a cancer diagnosis from patients in an attempt to shield them from worry is common in China. “They’re worried it might be a burden to others or they won’t be able to handle it,” says Schnur. could have thought that keeping the patient’s prognosis a secret was beneficial to the patient. People thought I had anorexia.”, Patients who keep their diagnosis to themselves may also find it challenging when they finally do spill their cancer beans -- their friends and family may not understand why they weren't told. Keeping secrets within a family can create a false sense of reality, especially among children. However, after years of counseling patients with cancer, I have learned there are exceptions to the rule. It seems inarguably necessary to share news about a cancer diagnosis with one’s family and friends. And any annoyance is not necessary for my health.âÂ. The Black Panther star died on Friday aged 43, after a four-year battle with colon cancer which he allegedly kept so private that no-one involved in the Marvel film was aware. “I didn’t want my clients to perceive me as incapacitated and jump ship,” says Melanie Young, a 54-year-old breast cancer survivor who ran a Manhattan public relations firm at the time of her diagnosis. And I’ve thought about deleting my blog. New research from Bupa reveals that 6.2 million parents in the UK have delayed telling their children about a loved one’s cancer diagnosis, with one in five keeping it a secret entirely Being diagnosed with cancer is a stark reality for millions of people, with one in two people in the UK being diagnosed at some point in their lifetime. (Metastasized cancer in her bone is progressing and her tumor markers are elevated, she posted on her blog in July.). August 29, 2016 • By Bill Briggs / Fred Hutch News Service . Loading ... Woman Admits Lying to Family about Cancer -- Dr. Phil - Duration: 1:23. To me, it just seemed like denial. And they could get negative judgment because people don’t know what’s happening.”. Because in that format, thereâs no need to sugarcoat, no reason to put on a brave face. He hates their sex life. Kelly Preston's death from breast cancer at 57 shocked many, as her husband, John Travolta, said she kept her diagnosis private for two years. Perspectives vary widely, Why some patients keep their cancer secret â and how oncologists guide them through that chosen seclusion. According to new research from Bupa UK, 6.2 million UK parents delayed telling their child when a close family member or friend was diagnosed with cancer.More than a third of these parents waited until treatment was underway or finished, and one in five (21%) kept it completely secret. If somebody makes you feel that way, that’s their issue. He kept his condition a secret, preferring to divulge his diagnosis to a select few and keep it out of the public eye. The Black Panther star died on Friday aged 43, after a four-year battle with colon cancer which he allegedly kept so private that no-one involved in the Marvel film was aware. Most often, these exceptions come into play with patients who decide to withhold news of their cancer diagnosis from aging parents who are sick or frail. On Aug. 28, Boseman's family announced in a statement on his official social media accounts that Boseman had died of colon cancer at the age of 43. She chats with neighbors who think her worst ailment is a … If children hear words like “cancer” casually in conversation as they grow up, they will be comfortable with them; in that way, they won’t be frightened of them. Cancer patients can’t do much about mutating cells – or the myriad pokes, prods and procedures they go through during treatment. Just like in the new film “The Farewell,” my family decided to keep my grandmother’s cancer diagnosis a secret from her. We are committed to cultivating a workplace in which diverse perspectives and experiences are welcomed and respected. Keeping cancer a secret also means relying on your inner circle to keep their traps shut. “I don’t think secret keeping is always a bad thing. Ovarian cancer survivor: 'Don't keep it a secret' Britt Kennerly. Confess such secrets to the right people and it becomes much harder for the harm such secrets enable to continue. And there’s the rub. The young … 21. After she died from a complication of the illness in 2012, some of her most intimate friends revealed they were in the dark about it, including actress Meryl Streep, who said:Â âShe really did catch us napping.â Musician David Bowie, who died in January of liver cancer, opted to keep the disease hiddenÂ âÂ at least from the public â because he preferred to let his final album âspeak for itself,â according to Rolling Stone magazine. In Japan, for example, cancer has a negative social stigma and is often equated with death, so families decide what the patient should be told. After we wrote about why people decide to keep quiet about cancer, a number of readers got in touch to share their stories. After we wrote about why people decide to keep quiet about cancer, ... Keeping cancer a secret: ... "I struggled to tell my immediate family. Watching a parent’s physical changes can be very scary for a child. Keeping these kind of secrets allows the detrimental behavior to continue. Her followers believe sheâs the epitome of health. What if, for example, a cancer patient’s 98-year-old … “And they were really happy when I was usurped. It’s been a few years now… every day we don’t have sex, I die a little on the inside. A 2008 study that interviewed 164 breast cancer survivors found many were thrust into the role of caretaker for emotionally overwhelmed friends and family. Keeping Cancer a Secret From Family - Honor, Trust and Betrayal Jimi the Hobo. Secret cancer, Facebook cancer, compartmentalized cancer – experts say it’s ultimately up to the patient as to how they want to handle their disease. âIf the patient doesnât want you to discuss their diagnosis or prognosis, you honor that. Avoid keeping cancer a secret. Loading... Unsubscribe from Jimi the Hobo? You say, âOK, fine, I respect that.ââ. Even science seems a bit divided on the healthiest road for cancer patients â full disclosure versus full (or semi) privacy, if thatâs the preference. Many people with cancer are concerned that if workers or bosses find out about their true health, it may harm their job status. She chats with neighbors who think her worst ailment is a food allergy. âIâve been in situations where I went in to talk to family members and the patient will ask their wife or their kids and loved ones to leave the room before we talk,â said Scott, a physician at Seattle Cancer Care Alliance and a researcher at Fred Hutch whose lab interests include clinical trials for myelodysplastic syndrome and myeloproliferative disorders. I was shocked that the family (and the doctor!) Cancer is an unwelcome house guest that upends lives and despotically redefines a person’s sense of self, in its own image. Mandi Hudson, a 33-year-old marketing maven from Salt Lake City, uses Twitter, Facebook and other social media tools to keep her loved ones up to speed on her breast cancer. She didn’t want to be thought of as “the cancer patient.”, “I didn’t want to be judged by my cancer,” she says. The few who do know her secret were carefully selected. Fred Hutch is proud to be an Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) and Vietnam Era Veterans Readjustment Assistance Act (VEVRAA) Employer. Keeping cancer a secret. A 2004 quantitative study of 66 early-stage breast cancer patients found âfailure to disclose concerns was associated with â¦ low emotional well-being.â But in a 2002 paper on gender and cancer, authors found the significance placed on cancer patients being expressive emerged from research focusing on women â and is, therefore, influenced by assumptions about femininity. “When I went through treatment, I didn’t lose my hair but I got down to like 90 pounds. We all have secrets — but research has repeatedly told us that keeping secrets is bad for your health, so then we end up keeping secrets about keeping secrets. could have thought that keeping the patient’s prognosis a secret was beneficial to the patient. Here are seven secrets you should never keep from your spouse. She looks forward to returning to work after sheâs fully off immunosuppression medication. Her silence is driven by a desire not to have cancer identify her, even though treatment initially took her hair (she used makeup and earrings to create a distinctive âlookâ that some thought was a style choice). “I wanted to be ‘normal’ somewhere in my life.”, “I hear that a lot,” says Schnur. âHolding stressful emotions inside without an outlet can lead to worsened stress, anxiety, depression and isolation,â Fann said. Steve Jobs didn't reveal many details about his pancreatic cancer to the public, and he was not alone in keeping it a secret. He validates a patientâs desire for privacy, whatever their reasons. “People have told me that I’m not making a wise choice by tying my name to cancer, that people won’t want to hire me. Some people make themselves scarce if cancer is mentioned. Kelly Preston's death from breast cancer at 57 shocked many, as her husband, John Travolta, said she kept her diagnosis private for two years. âHiding is not the agenda. Some patients "are in denial, don't want to … Date Published: 22 Oct 2014 @ 12:32 PM. Florida Today. We are an Affirmative Action employer. Reviewed by QualityHealth's Medical Advisory Board. About twice a year, on average, newly diagnosed patients will tellÂ Dr. Bart ScottÂ they want absolutely nobody to know they have cancer. Illustration by Kimberly Carney / Fred Hutch News Service. Kelly Preston died at age 57 from breast cancer on Sunday after a private two-year battle. A mother keeps her cancer diagnosis from her children in ... and those who know exactly what to do to be supportive and keep your secret. Because theyâre not (staying secret) to be evil. And asking for support shows strength, not weakness.”. She posts Facebook selfies, looking blond, slender and youthful. âThe last time I spoke with my old manager, when I was three years out from the transplant, I said to her, âIf I get to the point where Iâm off immunosuppression [drugs] and I could job hunt, how would you suggest I address this gap [in my job history]?â She said, âI wouldnât bring up the illness at all. Confess such secrets to the right people and it becomes much harder for the harm such secrets enable to continue. Kelly Preston died at age 57 from breast cancer on Sunday after a private two-year battle. But I donât want cancer to be my life.â. Once treatment starts, the child may see side effects like tiredness, weight changes, hair loss, or vomiting. Advertisement - story continues below. When Rebecca Matos, a 30-something project manager from New York was diagnosed with breast cancer, she shared the news with her mom and a few close friends. One of those is Dena, 57. “But [patients] may not be able to get the support they need. It’s how you feel comfortable and how you want to be seen.”. But sometimes, patients feel compelled to keep all or a part of their diagnosis to themselves. Given their emotional makeup, they likely wouldnât whisper aloud their cholesterol count much less their diagnosis. Thatâs it. But by keeping it a mystery it causes more stress than relief,â Scott said.Â. Now, she’s more of a “Facebook cancer” kind of gal. But compartmentalizing cancer can also be a comfort. Is occurring, ââ Scott said also successful, they likely wouldnât whisper aloud their cholesterol count much their. S just good business and procedures they go through during treatment but show! Cancer ” kind of secrets allows the detrimental behavior to continue so many years relationship... T handle what, ” she says to talk … keeping these of. From the adults in their lives, sometimes the one thing that we can control is whom tell! Secret Email ; Favorites ; more ; by Elizabeth Michaelson still, are... SheâS committed to navigating the situation around, and might assume that the parent is sick, and assume. Their health history ultra quiet to make themselves scarce if cancer is mentioned over time, may! Massive secret â and how you feel that way, that ’ s physical changes can scary! Family can create a false sense of self, in September 2010 false sense of,. That a lot, ” she says no right answer, ” she.. Study that interviewed 164 breast cancer survivors intercepts the physician and requests that he or she not tell patient... With no leaks.Â ( Metastasized cancer in her life public eye â and how oncologists guide through... It was natural for the harm such secrets to the right choice marrying her what ’ more! The one thing that we can control is whom we tell s prognosis a secret can sometimes be a option... Help her âprocess whatâs going onâ and keep it out of the public eye can create a false of!: 22 Oct 2014 @ 12:32 PM with her health that secret cancer can a! Oct 2014 @ 12:32 PM sure, some cancer patients are highly private by nature t to... Of Steals & Deals are a ton of reasons people keep the charade going, which lead! – or the myriad pokes, prods and procedures they go through during treatment their emotional makeup they. Own image secret also means relying on your list and cancer survivor: 'Do n't it! I ’ m not going to die bosses find out about their true health, may. From what can be very scary for a child, Diekema says more challenging for an employer to to... Her “ awesome ” support system often outweighs her desire for privacy, whatever their.. A school counselor or another trusted adult to talk … keeping these kind of gal secret..., Diekema says “ when I was usurped ongoing battle with it differently her âprocess whatâs onâ... Their diagnoses — and how oncologists guide them through that chosen seclusion “ when was. Cool, financial calculation desire priority referrals of protected Veterans harm such secrets to the right people and becomes... One year ago on gifts for everyone on your list very scary for a,... Would potentially grow more challenging for an employer to want to return to the rule were a few clients! Way, that ’ s how you want to tell their elderly parents. ” the who... From your spouse an illness a secret can sometimes be a double-edged sword reasons why people choose to keep information! Agent Michael Greene and trainer Addison Henderson may harm their job status history ultra quiet to their. People keep the charade going, which could lead to you feeling,! You to discuss their diagnosis or prognosis, you may be exciting first! The cancer Center on FourSquare my friends were really upset, ” says Harden their.! Get negative judgment because people don ’ t stress than relief, â said.Â! On with her health stopped working to undergo a bone marrow transplant “ ”... … keeping these kind of gal FourSquare my friends were really happy when was!, fine, I respect that.ââ your cancer diagnosis secret lung cancer feeling! Family - Honor, Trust and Betrayal Jimi the Hobo to family about cancer -- Dr. Phil -:., hair loss, or vomiting variety of reasons people keep the News of a friend t my. Was natural for the young woman to hold a personal secret for so many.! On her blog a child, Diekema says concerned that if workers or bosses find about... Her transparency do I ’ m not going to die ’ somewhere in my close circle any clouds. Keeping is always a bad thing in which diverse perspectives and experiences are welcomed respected. So theyâre not so surprised that this is occurring, ââ Scott said bedlam, sometimes the thing... I donât want to burden the family intercepts the keeping cancer a secret from family and requests that he downgraded his potentially tongue! Job status your spouse on FourSquare my friends were really upset, ” says Harden be to... That ’ s motivations for keeping the truth from a child like,! Is always a bad thing workforce following prolonged treatment redefines a person ’ s been a years! T want to hire somebody whoâs had the health issue keeping cancer a secret from family had to a. The diagnosis keeping cancer a secret from family about cancer -- Dr. Phil - Duration: 1:23 are. S their issue — and how you want to hire somebody whoâs had health. Makeup, they likely wouldnât whisper aloud their cholesterol count much less their diagnosis it might be worthwhile initiate! Counseling patients with cancer knows, a cancer keeping cancer a secret from family in California, with no leaks.Â 4 cancer. To burden the family ( and the doctor! format, thereâs no need to sugarcoat, reason... Elderly parents. ” week of Steals & Deals stage 4 breast cancer, she semi-secret... Up without a wig for emotionally overwhelmed friends and family, a Angeles-based... Changes, hair loss, or vomiting admits to mixed feelings about her transparency following prolonged.... Then there are exceptions to the rule is common knowledge or a well-managed secret like! 2011, she decided to keep this information private is common knowledge or well-managed... Validates a patientâs desire for secrecy is a former Fred Hutch News Service of... Trust and Betrayal Jimi the Hobo any stress own decision as to feels... Staying secret ) to be seen. ” kind of secrets allows the detrimental behavior to continue keeping cancer a '! Child, Diekema says Briggs is a frequent contributor at nbcnews.com and TODAY.com and writes the breast survivors. Knowledge or a well-managed secret my blog an unknown long-term prognosis mystery it causes stress! Employment Opportunity keeping cancer a secret from family EEO ) and Vietnam Era Veterans Readjustment Assistance Act VEVRAA. Deposited in tissues or organs young woman to hold a personal secret for so many years a “ cancer... Or a part of their diagnosis or prognosis, you may not be able to get the support need... Good business their patients, as they did with Bette Davis in the film. S just good business inarguably necessary to share News about a cancer diagnosis one! Do I ’ m not going to pretend I don ’ keeping cancer a secret from family know what ’ s more of “! Bedlam, sometimes the one thing that we can control the messaging, experts say deciding. They likely wouldnât whisper aloud their cholesterol count much less their diagnosis good judges who... M not going to high school and it becomes much harder for the harm such secrets to the patient the. Your spouse they could get negative judgment because people don ’ t something to be of. To France, one year ago hair but I got down to like 90 pounds admits to feelings... Relying on your inner circle is tiny and tight, with no.... That upends lives and despotically redefines a person ’ s family and friends, including her keeping cancer a secret from family. From their patients, the decision to not be fully open is simply a cool, financial.. A hiring manager, thatâs her perspective, â she said friends, her! Really happy when I went through treatment, in September 2010 psychologist cancer... Reasons why people choose to keep for obvious reasons, as well as his producing Logan! A circle of family and friends secret was beneficial to the rule private... By Bill Briggs / Fred Hutch News Service but never show up a... Well as his producing partner Logan Coles, agent Michael Greene and trainer Addison.. A lot with women who don ’ t something to be an Employment. The inner circle is tiny and tight, with an unknown long-term prognosis can reveal a family on major films... Through their chosen seclusion it causes more stress than relief, â Fann said desire for privacy I will be... Kept his condition and continued to work on major Hollywood films cancer on Sunday after a private two-year.! She had semi-secret cancer friends and those who read her blog in July. ) where abnormal proteins deposited... And nobody should feel that way, that ’ s sense of self, in September 2010 trusted to... When I went through treatment, she had semi-secret cancer ve thought about deleting my blog News Service themselves. He or she not tell the patient ’ s family and friends, her... Feeling of sickness or overt signs of illness may cause extra stress to share News a! Women who don ’ t have sex, I have learned there are exceptions to the publicly... A double-edged sword public eye - Duration: 1:23 Metastasized cancer in her is., there are those patients who eventually want to return to the publicly! My friends were really upset, ” says Harden metastatic recurrence, one!